Monroe County · Florida
Plantation Key Courthouse
Small claims court for the Upper Keys Division of Monroe County, Florida
Address
88770 Overseas Highway, Suite 2, Tavernier, FL 33070
Small claims limit
$8,000 or less
Pretrial conference
Set within 50 days of filing
Clerk's office
Suite 2, Plantation Key Government Center · Monday to Friday, 8:30 am to 5:00 pm
About this courthouse
The Upper Keys court sits in the Plantation Key Government Center at 88770 Overseas Highway, at mile marker 88. The Clerk and the court are in different suites. The Clerk's small claims office is Suite 2, and the circuit lists the court in Suite 1. The Clerk's phone here is 305-852-7145 and the fax is 305-852-7146.
Plantation Key is the seat of the County Court's Upper Keys Division. The Upper Keys Division judge hears all assigned County Court cases in the Plantation Key Division. The judge's office is at (305) 852-7155, [email protected].
Key West, Marathon or Plantation Key: which office takes your case?
The Clerk's small claims FAQ says to bring your Statement of Claim to one of three offices: Key West, Marathon or Plantation Key. It does not give a rule for which office to use.
The office you choose decides your judge. Administrative Order 2.005/25-2, effective October 20, 2025, splits the County Court caseload by the geographic division in which the case is filed: Lower Keys, Middle Keys or Upper Keys. The order says it only distributes cases between judges. It does not give anyone a right to a particular judge or court.
The court has a list that ties ZIP codes to courthouses, but that list is for jury duty only. It is not a rule for where to file a small claim.
This courthouse
Plantation Key Courthouse
88770 Overseas Highway, Suite 2, Tavernier, FL 33070
Also in Monroe County
Monroe County Courthouse
500 Whitehead Street, Key West, FL 33040
Also in Monroe County
Marathon Courthouse
3117 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050
How a small claims case moves through this court
- 1
Prepare
Fill out the Clerk's Statement of Claim. You must sign it and swear to it in front of a notary or a deputy clerk, in person or by online notarization. The form asks for the phone number and e-mail address of both sides, and you state that the defendant is not in the military service of the United States. If your case is based on a written document, such as a contract, lease or promissory note, the Clerk's instructions say you must attach a copy.
- 2
File
Florida small claims court handles claims of $8,000 or less. You can file through the Florida Courts E-Filing Portal or with the Clerk. Once the Statement of Claim is filed, the Clerk issues a summons that sets the date and time of your Pre-Trial Conference.
- 3
Serve
The Clerk's instructions say a defendant located in Florida may be served by certified mail or by the Sheriff. A defendant outside Florida must be served by the Sheriff. You may also use a private process server. The Sheriff cannot serve a P.O. Box, and if service fails, finding a better address is up to you.
- 4
Pre-Trial
The Clerk's instructions say the Pre-Trial Conference is there to determine the nature of the case, schedule a mediation session and schedule a trial if one is needed. Do not bring witnesses. If the defendant has not been served by that date, the Court moves the date. You must still appear unless you tell the Court in advance that service has not been made.
- 5
Mediation
Every small claims case in Monroe County is set for mediation and must go to mediation before it is set for trial. The Clerk's instructions say missed mediations are rescheduled, and repeated failure to appear may lead to dismissal.
Forms
The Clerk publishes five small claims forms: Instructions for Small Claims Court Cases, Statement of Claim, Authorization of Principal, Satisfaction of Judgment, and Notice of Voluntary Dismissal. The Statement of Claim lists eleven causes of action to check, including rent due, auto collision damage, money loaned, recovery of personal property located in Monroe County, and recovery of property from a pawnbroker.
If you are a business
A business may be represented by a corporate officer, or by an employee who has written authorization from an officer and brings it to the Pre-Trial Conference. The Clerk's Authorization of Principal form lets a principal name an employee to represent the business at any stage, including mediation, with full settlement authority. It is signed under penalties of perjury and has no notary block.
Jury trial
The Clerk's FAQ says a plaintiff who wants a jury trial must ask in writing when filing. A defendant may ask within five days after service of notice or at the pretrial conference.
If you settle
The Clerk's instructions say the plaintiff must notify the Clerk, then file a Notice of Voluntary Dismissal and give a copy to the defendant.
After judgment
A certified copy of a final judgment is available 10 days after entry, according to the Clerk's FAQ. After a judgment is paid, the plaintiff must file a Satisfaction of Judgment within 30 days or risk sanctions.
Phones in court
Administrative Order 2.069 requires cell phones and other personal communication devices to be off during all court proceedings. A violation can mean contempt and confiscation of the device.
Interpreters
Administrative Order 2.066/22-1 lists the kinds of cases in which the court appoints spoken-language interpreters. Small claims and county civil cases are not on that list. The court does appoint a sign-language interpreter for any person who needs one in all proceedings. Send sign-language requests to [email protected].
Disability accommodations
The circuit's ADA Coordinator can be reached by phone at (305) 295-3652, fax (305) 292-3435, e-mail [email protected]. The court's ADA page links a Request for Accommodation form.
Court holidays
The court is open Monday to Friday, 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM. In 2026 it closes on Thursday November 26, Friday November 27, Thursday December 24 and Friday December 25, among other holidays. It also observes Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur and Good Friday.
Checking a business
To check a business before you sue, the Clerk points to the Secretary of State at 850-488-1234 or sunbiz.org. For unregistered businesses, the Clerk points to the Occupational License Department of the Monroe County Tax Collector.
Finding a lawyer
The Clerk's small claims FAQ refers people who want a lawyer to the Florida Bar Referral Service at 1-800-342-8011.
Visiting the courthouse
Parking
The court says to park in the courthouse parking lot.
Security and what you cannot bring
Monroe County Sheriff's deputies screen everyone who enters with a magnetometer and an x-ray of belongings. Firearms, weapons, explosives, hazardous devices, mace or pepper spray and contraband are prohibited.
Hours
The Clerk's office is open Monday to Friday, 8:30 am to 5:00 pm.
Interpreters and accessibility
The Upper Keys Division judge's page lists [email protected], (305) 853-7345, as the interpreter contact. For ADA accommodations it lists [email protected].
Exhibits
Hearing exhibits go to the Clerk in hard copy at least 5 days before the hearing. Label them "Exhibit A for Identification", "Exhibit B for Identification" and so on.
88770 Overseas Highway, Suite 2, Tavernier, FL 33070
Questions about this court
Which suite do I go to at the Plantation Key Government Center?
The Clerk's small claims office is Suite 2. The circuit lists the court in Suite 1. Both are at 88770 Overseas Highway.
Can I attend a Plantation Key hearing remotely?
The Upper Keys Division runs a hybrid courtroom on Zoom. A remote appearance needs a motion filed 10 days before the hearing and the court's permission in advance.
Which Plantation Key hearings can be held remotely?
In the Upper Keys Division, non-evidentiary motions of 30 minutes or less may be heard remotely. Evidentiary hearings and hearings over 30 minutes are in person unless all parties agree otherwise.
How do I label exhibits for the Plantation Key court?
Label them "Exhibit A for Identification", "Exhibit B for Identification" and so on. They go to the Clerk in hard copy at least 5 days before the hearing.
Sources
- Monroe County Clerk: small claims FAQs
- Sixteenth Judicial Circuit: courthouse locations and maps
- Sixteenth Judicial Circuit: Upper Keys Division judge's page
- Sixteenth Judicial Circuit: jury information (parking)
- Administrative Order 2.064: judicial facility security and screening
- Administrative Order 2.090: special jury district for Monroe County
Court details change. Confirm dates, rooms and fees with the court before you go. Last checked November 18, 2026.