Monroe County Small Claims Courts
Monroe County, Florida hears small claims at 3 courthouses. Claims of $8,000 or less.
Key West, Marathon or Plantation Key: which office takes your case?
The Clerk's small claims FAQ says to bring your Statement of Claim to one of three offices: Key West, Marathon or Plantation Key. It does not give a rule for which office to use.
The office you choose decides your judge. Administrative Order 2.005/25-2, effective October 20, 2025, splits the County Court caseload by the geographic division in which the case is filed: Lower Keys, Middle Keys or Upper Keys. The order says it only distributes cases between judges. It does not give anyone a right to a particular judge or court.
The court has a list that ties ZIP codes to courthouses, but that list is for jury duty only. It is not a rule for where to file a small claim.
Monroe County Courthouse
500 Whitehead Street, Key West, FL 33040
Small claims court for the Lower Keys Division of Monroe County, Florida
Marathon Courthouse
3117 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050
Small claims court for the Middle Keys Division of Monroe County, Florida
Plantation Key Courthouse
88770 Overseas Highway, Suite 2, Tavernier, FL 33070
Small claims court for the Upper Keys Division of Monroe County, Florida
Want the cost before you start? Florida court cost calculator
Ready to file in Monroe County?
Flash Justice helps you organize and file your small claims case in minutes.
Start Now