Flash Justice

Sarasota County · Florida

Sarasota County Historic Courthouse

Where North County small claims cases are filed in Sarasota County, Florida. Hearings are next door at 2002 Ringling Blvd.

Address

2000 Main St., Sarasota, FL 34237

Small claims limit

$8,000 or less

Pretrial conference

Set within 50 days of filing

Clerk's office

Room 102, 1st floor (Customer Services) · Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.

About this courthouse

The Historic Courthouse on Main Street is where you file a small claims case in person in Sarasota, but it is not where your case is heard. The Clerk of the Circuit Court is the only office still in the building. The Clerk's Customer Services counter is in Room 102 on the 1st floor, and Public Access Records is in Room 103.

The North County county civil judges sit next door in the Judge Lynn N. Silvertooth Judicial Center, 2002 Ringling Blvd. Divisions A, B and C list courtrooms 5C, 2B and 4A there. That building was built in 1998, is 11 stories high with 16 courtrooms, and was renamed in 2006 for Judge Lynn N. Silvertooth. He was a lifelong Sarasota resident who was appointed circuit judge in 1964 and served until retiring in 1988.

Sarasota takes the county civil cases that do not meet the South County tests. In practice that is the part of the county north of the east-west line along Blackburn Point Road.

County commissioners hired architect Dwight James Baum in 1925 to design the courthouse in the Mediterranean Revival style. Baum also designed Ca' d'Zan. The building has Samuel Yellin-styled ironwork, terrazzo floors, marble walls, a bell tower, red barrel roof tiles, a courtyard garden and a Historic Courtroom with pecky cypress beams.

Does your case belong in Sarasota or Venice?

Sarasota County splits county civil cases, including small claims, between two places: Sarasota (North County) and the South County Courthouse in Venice. The dividing line runs east and west along Blackburn Point Road and continues to the county's eastern boundary. Everything south of that line is the South County Judicial District.

The rule comes from Twelfth Circuit Administrative Order 2026-12.2, signed August 27, 2026 by the Chief Judge. Under that order, a case that meets any one of the tests below is filed in Venice. All other cases go to Sarasota.

If a case is filed in the wrong place, the order lets the Clerk transfer it between South County and Sarasota in either direction.

  • The defendant lives in the South County District (south of Blackburn Point Road): Venice
  • The defendant lives in Charlotte County: Venice
  • The cause of action arose in the South County District: Venice
  • The property in the case is in the South County District: Venice
  • None of the above: Sarasota

This courthouse

Sarasota County Historic Courthouse

2000 Main St., Sarasota, FL 34237

Also in Sarasota County

South County Courthouse

4004 S. Tamiami Trail, Venice, FL 34293

How a small claims case moves through this court

  1. 1

    File

    Florida small claims court handles claims of $8,000 or less. You can file through the Florida Courts E-Filing Portal, or in person at the Historic Courthouse in Sarasota or the South County Courthouse in Venice. The Clerk publishes seven Statement of Claim forms: General, Auto Negligence, Goods Sold, Money Lent, Return of Stolen Property, Work Done and Materials Furnished, and Promissory Note. The Clerk says you must attach copies of contracts, notes, leases, receipts or other evidence, and provide one identical copy of every document for each defendant.

  2. 2

    Serve

    Each defendant must be served. The Sarasota County Sheriff's Office charges $40 per service for a summons. For each person served, the Sheriff needs one original or certified copy, one copy of the process and one copy of the complaint. The Clerk also offers service by certified mail, but only for defendants who are Florida residents. You arrange and pay for it at the Clerk's Sarasota or Venice office. For a defendant outside Sarasota County, the Clerk says to contact the Civil Division of the sheriff in the defendant's county and include a postage-paid envelope addressed to the Sarasota Clerk for return of the service documents.

  3. 3

    Pretrial

    The Clerk says the first court date is a mediation and pre-trial conference, and that you should be prepared to present your case. The pretrial dockets are called by the director of the Sarasota County Mediation Program. The judges' pages say that failing to appear after proper notice may result in a default judgment or dismissal. The Clerk also says the judge may dismiss the claim if the plaintiff does not appear on the scheduled court date.

  4. 4

    Mediation

    When both parties attend the pretrial, the case is scheduled for mediation. The judges' requirements say mediation is mandatory before a small claims trial date may be set. Mediators are free for small claims cases in the Twelfth Circuit's County Civil Mediation Program. If you settle, both sides sign a stipulation that the judge signs and the clerk files. If the other party does not comply, the court's mediation page says the plaintiff may obtain a judgment by filing an affidavit with the clerk describing the non-compliance.

  5. 5

    Trial

    If the dispute is not settled, a trial date is set. Small claims trials in Sarasota County are not recorded. A party who wants a record must hire a court reporter at their own expense. The court's trial instructions say written repair estimates are usually not accepted as evidence unless both parties agree or the person who wrote the estimate testifies.

  6. 6

    After judgment

    The Clerk's page says a judgment debtor has 10 days to file a motion for a new trial and 30 days to file an appeal.

Moving your pretrial date

A request to continue a small claims Pretrial Conference must be in writing and filed with the Clerk, with copies to the Judicial Assistant and all parties. Division B requires the motion to be filed at least two business days before the Pretrial Conference.

Going straight to mediation

Parties who want to skip the Pretrial Conference and go straight to mediation may file a Stipulation for Small Claims Mediation form at least two days before the Pretrial Conference.

If a defendant is not served in time

In Divisions C and E, if the plaintiff has not served all defendants before the Pretrial Conference, the case stays open without the plaintiff appearing. The plaintiff must then obtain a new summons to get a new court date.

If the defendant does not appear

When a defendant fails to appear at the Pretrial Conference or mediation, the court provides an "Affidavit of Damages After Default" form. A separate "Affidavit of Damages After Breach of Settlement Agreement" form is also provided.

Jury trial

The Clerk says the plaintiff may request a jury trial in writing when filing. The defendant may request one within five days after being served with the Notice to Appear, or at the mediation and pre-trial conference.

Counterclaims

A defendant who wants to file a counterclaim after the pretrial conference must make the request in writing, file it with the Clerk and send a copy to the other party.

Photos and video on your phone

If you want to show photos or video stored on a phone or device at trial, the court says you must confer with its IT department before trial. The evidence must be in a format that stays with the Court once it is admitted.

If you settle before trial

The court's page says to notify the Judge's office by phone at (941) 861-7956 right away. Send the original signed settlement agreement to the Clerk, with a copy to the Judge's office. The Clerk also requires any settlement, and any change of mailing address, to be reported to the Clerk's Office in writing.

Viewing your case online

Case documents can be viewed on the Clerk's ClerkNet at secure.sarasotaclerk.com/AnonLanding.aspx. Search the case number in the format YYYY XX 999999 XX. The court's handout says to wait 5 days after a hearing for the order or final judgment to appear.

Interpreters

The Twelfth Circuit does not schedule interpreters automatically for civil events. The person who needs one must submit the online Interpreter Request Form at least 5 days before the proceeding. Requests with less than 5 business days' notice may not be honored. Each court event must be requested separately, and you cannot ask for a specific interpreter.

Disability accommodations

ADA accommodation requests for Sarasota County court proceedings go to the Sarasota County Jury Office, P.O. Box 3079, Sarasota, FL 34230-3079, (941) 861-8000. Hearing- or voice-impaired callers dial 711. Sign language interpreters and real-time reporting need more lead time. The Twelfth Circuit ADA Coordinator can be reached at (941) 749-3600 ext. 1791.

Mediation before you file

The Twelfth Circuit's free Citizen Dispute Settlement Program offers mediation before a case is filed, usually within three weeks, when both sides agree to take part. The Sarasota phone number is (941) 861-7833.

Legal help

Court staff cannot give legal advice. The Clerk's small claims FAQ refers people who want legal guidance to the Sarasota County Bar Association (sarasotabar.com) and Legal Aid of Manasota (legalaidofmanasota.org). The court's small claims page lists the Florida Bar Lawyer Referral Service at (800) 342-8011.

Visiting the courthouse

Hours

The Clerk's office in the Historic Courthouse is open Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. The Silvertooth Judicial Center keeps the same hours, and its phone number is (941) 861-7800. The judicial offices for County Civil Divisions A, B and C are open 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. and close for lunch from noon to 1 p.m.

Getting there

The Clerk's driving directions: from I-75 take exit 210 (Fruitville Rd.) about 5 miles west to East Avenue. Turn left, then right onto Main Street. The courthouse is on the left.

Parking

The parking garage at 2150 Ringling Blvd., at the southeast corner of Ringling and School Avenue, is entered from School Avenue and has a lot and five parking floors. The court's page says it offers free parking for longer periods. The Clerk says all parking except the garage is subject to time limits and enforcement. Main Street and Ringling Boulevard have on-street parking, and the court's page says most nearby downtown streets have free two- and three-hour parking. The Main Street Parking Lot is across from the courthouse at the northeast corner of Main Street and U.S. 301 / Washington Blvd., entered from Fletcher Avenue. The Judicial Parking lot at 2050 Ringling Boulevard has pay kiosks that take credit and debit cards.

Accessibility

The Clerk's office has street-level access only through the Ringling Boulevard entrance. Two disabled parking spaces are on the north side of Ringling Blvd. next to that entrance. The Historic Courtroom and the Law and Order Cafe have ramp access from the east side of the building, reached from Main Street, where there is one disabled parking space between the courthouse and the Sheriff's Jail entrance. The Silvertooth Judicial Center has ramps on the east and west sides of its main entrance. The parking garage has disabled spaces near the elevators on all five floors.

Self Help Center

The Lee E. Haworth Self Help Center and Law Library is on the 1st Floor of the Silvertooth Judicial Center, 2002 Ringling Blvd., phone (941) 861-8191. Walk-ins are first come, first served, and appointments are strongly encouraged. It offers forms, limited procedural assistance for family law and some civil matters, public computers with Fastcase and free printing for legal research. It does not give legal advice. Visitors go through security screening, phones must be silenced, and no food, beverages, gum or tobacco are allowed.

Sheriff's Civil Section

If you use the Sheriff to serve your summons, the Civil Section is on the 1st Floor at 2071 Ringling Blvd., Sarasota, FL 34237, phone 941.861.4110. That is the Sarasota County Justice Center, across the street from the Silvertooth Judicial Center.

Mail and overnight delivery

The Clerk's mailing address is P.O. Box 3079, Sarasota, FL 34230-3079. Overnight mail goes to the street address, 2000 Main Street, Sarasota, FL 34237. The Clerk does not accept court filings by e-mail.

2000 Main St., Sarasota, FL 34237

Questions about this court

Is my small claims hearing held inside the Historic Courthouse?

No. The Historic Courthouse holds the Clerk's office. The North County county civil judges sit next door at the Judge Lynn N. Silvertooth Judicial Center, 2002 Ringling Blvd. Divisions A, B and C list courtrooms 5C, 2B and 4A.

Where in the Historic Courthouse do I file a small claims case?

At the Clerk's Customer Services counter in Room 102 on the 1st floor. The office is open Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. Street-level access is only through the Ringling Boulevard entrance.

Where can I park without watching the clock?

The Clerk says all parking except the garage is subject to time limits and enforcement. The garage is at 2150 Ringling Blvd., at the corner of Ringling and School Avenue, and you enter from School Avenue. The court's page says it offers free parking for longer periods.

Can I try mediation in downtown Sarasota before I file?

Yes, if both sides agree. The Twelfth Circuit's free Citizen Dispute Settlement Program has its Sarasota location on the 6th Floor of the Sarasota County Criminal Justice Center, 2071 Ringling Blvd. The phone number is (941) 861-7833.

Sources

Court details change. Confirm dates, rooms and fees with the court before you go. Last checked November 18, 2026.

Flash Justice is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney, and does not establish an attorney-client relationship.

Contact us

Select Language

··